How Do You Negotiate the Best Offer When You Sell Your House in MA or NH?
The quick answer: The best offer is the one most likely to close, not just the highest number. Sellers in Andover MA, Haverhill MA and Salem NH win by setting up the sale before offers arrive, comparing the loan, conditions and dates side by side, and answering inspection requests calmly. Your attorney locks the final terms in the P&S.
The best offer isn't always the highest one. It's the one most likely to close.
Picture three offers on your screen. One is the highest. One matches your price. One is a little lower, with cash and a flexible moving date. Which one do you take?
If that question makes your stomach flip, you aren't alone. It feels like one wrong click could cost you. The good news is that most of the work happens long before that moment.
I've trained with former FBI hostage negotiators, and here's what I've learned. Calm, prepared sellers win. Here's how we get you there.
Most of the negotiation happens before the first buyer walks in.
In this guide
How do you set up the negotiation before offers arrive?
You set it up with the price you choose, the way the home shows and the way we launch it. By the time offers come, the hard part is done.
When many buyers see your home in the same few days, they make offers at the same time. That's the heart of my 6 Day Selling Strategy. Almost all of my sellers accept their chosen buyer on day 6, right on time. My listings reach over 40,000 people on average, so the buyer pool is wide from day one.
When one buyer trickles in at a time, you negotiate alone with each one. When buyers arrive together, you choose.
How are offers handled on an LSG listing?
We set the offer deadline, the review window and the response window. You stay in control.
No midnight deadlines. No four-hour pressure windows from a buyer. Offers come in by the set time and stay open long enough for you to think.
Every offer must come with the same package, so you can compare fairly:
- The signed offer
- A loan commitment or pre-approval letter
- A short letter outlining the offer
- Written word on whether the buyer needs to sell another home first
- The lender's contact information
- Whether the buyer's agent has a past personal relationship with the buyer
How do you compare offers side by side?
Look at six things together: price, net to you, the loan, the conditions, the dates and how sure the buyer is to close.
Net to you. Two offers at the same price aren't the same if one asks for a credit.
The loan. Cash removes loan risk. A pre-approval means a lender checked the buyer's income, assets and credit. A pre-qualification is lighter. We call the lender to confirm.
Conditions. Each condition, like an inspection or a loan approval, gives the buyer a way out. Fewer and shorter conditions mean less risk for you.
Dates. A move date that fits your plan can be worth more than a small bump in price.
What's an escalation clause, and should you like one?
An escalation clause says a buyer will beat any other offer by a set amount, up to a cap. It shows you how high that buyer is willing to go.
Before you lean on one, we check three things. Is the step size real? Can the cap pass the bank appraisal? Does the clause ask to see the other offer? Some do, so you'll want to know before you agree.
Which conditions should a seller watch most closely?
Watch the inspection, the loan approval and the appraisal. Each one has a deadline, and each one can reopen the deal.
The appraisal is the bank's check on value. If it comes in under the price, the buyer may ask you to lower it, bring more cash or meet in the middle. That's why a high price with a full appraisal condition is different from a high price where the buyer agrees to cover a gap.
On the loan, a buyer who's fully underwritten carries less risk than one with a quick letter. Shorter loan deadlines are often fair to ask for when the buyer is strong.
Why does the P&S matter so much?
The P&S, or purchase and sale agreement, is the full contract you sign after accepting the offer. It locks in the final price, dates, credits and deadlines.
Some sellers treat it like paperwork. It isn't. Your attorney reviews every draft and flags anything that's changed from the accepted offer. Any repair or credit you agree to after inspection goes in writing. A promise made in a hallway doesn't close.
If your home was built before 1978, Massachusetts also requires you to give the buyer a lead paint notice before you sign the P&S.
How should you answer inspection requests?
Sort every request into three groups: real safety or structure issues, normal wear, and small cosmetic notes. Then answer each group differently.
Real issues deserve a fair answer, often a credit instead of a repair. A credit keeps you in control of the cost and avoids repair fights at closing. Normal wear and cosmetic notes usually don't.
Here's a true one. Buyers once asked my seller to pay for a bigger water heater, even though the old one worked fine. I called the buyer's agent and asked what the buyers were really worried about. We talked it through for about twenty minutes. The reply came back, "We're all set." My seller paid for nothing.
The goal is a closed sale at a fair price, not winning an argument.
Where has the Lisa Sevajian Group sold homes?
All across Massachusetts and New Hampshire, from Andover MA and North Andover MA to Haverhill MA, Newburyport MA and Salem NH. Tap a dot to see the sale.
For sellers getting ready for offers
Want help reading your offers?
Sign up and we'll set your offer deadline and review plan before the first showing.
About Lisa Sevajian
Lisa Sevajian is a Realtor with the Lisa Sevajian Group at eXp Realty, licensed in Massachusetts and New Hampshire. She has guided almost 2,000 families through buying and selling and has ranked in the top 1.5% of over 1.4 million Realtors nationwide, verified by RealTrends. She serves the Andovers, the Merrimack Valley, Seacoast MA and NH, Southern NH and the North Shore. Buying, she makes sure you don't overpay. Selling, she makes sure you don't say yes to too little. Call Lisa Sevajian at 978-457-3406.
Home, for me, is here
This is home for me. I grew up north of Boston. I raised my two daughters here as a single mom while I built my business. When they were little, they hosted open houses with me.
We lived at Mill Pond in North Andover MA. I hiked Weir Hill with my dogs. I launched my kayak on the pond. A lot of my mornings started at Good Day Cafe.
So when you ask me about a town, you get more than numbers. Ask me about a school, a street or your commute, and you get someone who has lived it. If you're making a move here, you won't make it alone.
Lisa is an expert negotiator and we were able to get everything that we wanted for our offer.
Kevin Liu, bought a home in Georgetown MA, verified Zillow review
She listened to me and understood what I needed in this home sale.
Elizabeth Reifsnyder, sold a home in Andover MA, verified Zillow review
Read real client storiesSee all reviewsMore about Lisa Sevajian
Featured by HGTV, Forbes, HousingWire, Boston magazine, RealTrends Verified and Boston Agent Magazine, syndicated by The Globe and Mail and Yahoo Finance, among many others.
Questions people ask
How do I choose between multiple offers on my house in Massachusetts?
Compare price, your net, the loan, the conditions, the dates and how sure each buyer is to close. The best offer is the one most likely to close.
Is the highest offer always the best when selling in Andover MA?
No. In Andover MA, a slightly lower offer with cash or a strong loan and few conditions can be safer than the top number.
What's an escalation clause in a real estate offer?
It's a promise to beat any other offer by a set amount, up to a cap. It shows how high the buyer will go, but check the cap against the likely appraisal.
What should be included with every offer on my house in Haverhill MA?
On an LSG listing in Haverhill MA, every offer comes with the signed offer, a pre-approval or loan commitment, an offer letter, the lender's contact and whether the buyer must sell a home first.
How do I handle inspection requests when selling in North Andover MA?
Sort requests into real issues, normal wear and cosmetic notes. In North Andover MA and everywhere else, a credit for real issues usually works better than repairs.
What's the difference between pre-approval and pre-qualification?
A pre-approval means a lender checked the buyer's income, assets and credit. A pre-qualification is a lighter estimate, so it carries more risk for a seller.
What happens if the appraisal is low when I sell in Methuen MA?
The buyer and seller in Methuen MA can agree on a new price, the buyer can add cash, or you can meet in the middle.
When do you sign the P&S in Massachusetts?
After the offer is accepted, both attorneys draft and review the purchase and sale agreement. It locks in the final price, dates and deadlines.
Can I set an offer deadline when selling in Salem NH?
Yes. On an LSG listing in Salem NH, the listing team sets the offer deadline, the review window and the response window, with no midnight deadlines.
Should I give a credit or make repairs after the inspection?
A credit usually keeps you in control of the cost and avoids repair disputes at closing. Your attorney puts the agreed credit in writing.
Do I need a lead paint form before the P&S in Massachusetts?
Yes, if the home was built before 1978. Give the buyer the Property Transfer Lead Paint Notification before you sign the P&S.
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: prequalification vs preapproval letters (checked October 14, 2026)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: when the appraisal is less than the sale price (checked October 14, 2026)
- Massachusetts Department of Public Health: Property Transfer Lead Paint Notification (checked October 14, 2026)
This is general information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Check with your attorney, lender and CPA before you decide.
I'll guide you home.
Lisa Sevajian